ICEE Released A Mermaid Mystery-Flavored Ice Pop

Mystery flavors seem to be having a moment right now. Gushers has gotten in on it, along with Fun Dip and Kool-Aid. Now, there’s a new mystery food you can add to the bunch: mystery ICEEs.

ICEE just released a new, limited-edition pack of popsicles that includes a—wait for it—Mystery Mermaid flavor. Instagram account @Markie_Devo shared photos of the sweet treat, and it basically looks like summer in a box.

“@samsclub is selling a 32 tube box of @official_icee_co and there is a mystery Mermaid flavor (thank god not Unicorn) inside along with Cherry, Sour Apple, and Blue Raspberry,” he wrote. “I’m not sure what this mystery flavor is, but If I could take a guess lime/berry of some sort (due to the color).”

People were pretty excited in the comments. “’My kids ate the whole box.’ That’s my story and I’m sticking to it,” one person wrote. “I ❤️ me some icees! #itsgreat,” someone else said. “Damn,” another person said. No more words needed.

Since there are four flavors in a 32-pack, you get eight chances to try to figure out what the heck a mermaid tastes like. Salty lime? Seaweed? Something completely random?

The $9.28 pack is already for sale on the Sam’s Club website, which helpfully points out that these treats are gluten-free and kosher. As the weather heats up, we’ll definitely be looking for these in the freezer aisles to help us cool down.